Case todayNot read todayThesis-Break EngineThe case · holding · Nov 21, 2026Own NTB if its island deposit base, fiduciary relationships, and capital returns prove more durable than a rate-sensitive bank multiple implies.5 conditions3 strengthening · 2 holdingNext resultsNot scheduledNo date filed yet

NTB at a glance

The past year

Chart

+19.0% $53.61, close Nov 20

From the highest close
−16.1%
Vs the 200-day average
−6.0%
Nov 19, 2025Daily close, Bank of N.T. Butterfield & SonNov 20, 2026

Short interest

History

694,046 shares

Since the last report
−13.6%
Days to cover
4.2 days
Settled
Oct 30, 2026

Insider buying, 7 days

Filings

$541,779 bought on the open market

Purchases
1
Form 4s filed
Nov 16 – Nov 22

Understand the Business

Why the Stock Moved

Period-matched expectations history is not yet available. Current metrics are not a substitute for a historical explanation.

NTB price history

Latest price$53.63Today−$0.24 (-0.45%)
NTB -9.77%S&P 500 -10.82%Since first plotted close
4 hours

Loading recent earnings…

Investment thesis

What must happen next

5 MATERIAL PROPOSITIONS
  • Butterfield’s offshore relationship franchise lets it convert client deposits and liquidity into spread revenue without needing aggressive asset growth.StrengtheningMateriality: High

    GAAP annual revenue increased from $499.7 million in FY2021 to $606.8 million in FY2025. If this holds, owners get a capital-light, high-return bank; if deposits reprice or leave, earnings power can fall before the balance sheet visibly shrinks.

    Watch: Bermuda, Cayman or Channel Islands customers move operating cash into U.S. Treasury funds, money-market funds or global private-bank sweep products.

    Supporting sources

    Source notes are factual paraphrases; read the original disclosures below.

    GAAP annual revenue increased from $499.7 million in FY2021 to $606.8 million in FY2025.

    Open source ↗
  • Trust, wealth and custody-style client relationships should make Butterfield less volatile than a loan-growth bank, provided offshore clients keep mandates with the platform.HoldingMateriality: High

    GAAP annual net income stayed high across FY2022-FY2025, ranging from $214.0 million to $231.9 million. Persistent fee and relationship income would support a higher-quality earnings stream; mandate losses would make profits more cyclical and easier to underwrite at a lower multiple.

    Watch: Global fiduciary competitors such as Northern Trust, HSBC or major private banks win offshore trust and custody mandates from Butterfield clients.

    Supporting sources

    Source notes are factual paraphrases; read the original disclosures below.

    GAAP annual net income stayed high across FY2022-FY2025, ranging from $214.0 million to $231.9 million.

    Open source ↗
  • Butterfield’s value creation depends on conservative liquidity and credit discipline, because a small offshore bank has less room to absorb deposit flight, securities losses or localized credit shocks.StrengtheningMateriality: Medium

    GAAP stockholders’ equity increased from $864.8 million at FY2022 year-end to $1.14 billion at FY2025 year-end. A clean, liquid balance sheet keeps capital available for dividends, buybacks and client confidence; a credit or liquidity event would reprice the franchise sharply.

    Watch: A tourism, commercial real estate or captive-insurance downturn in Butterfield’s island markets creates outsized credit losses.

    Supporting sources

    Source notes are factual paraphrases; read the original disclosures below.

    GAAP stockholders’ equity increased from $864.8 million at FY2022 year-end to $1.14 billion at FY2025 year-end.

    Open source ↗
  • Excess capital can compound owner value through per-share growth only if regulators and balance-sheet needs allow Butterfield to keep returning capital instead of retaining it defensively.StrengtheningMateriality: Medium

    GAAP diluted EPS rose from $3.26 in FY2021 to $5.47 in FY2025. This is the bridge from a good bank to a good stock: capital return can lift diluted EPS, but it disappears quickly if capital buffers need rebuilding.

    Watch: Bermuda or other regulators require higher capital buffers, limiting dividends or buybacks.

    Supporting sources

    Source notes are factual paraphrases; read the original disclosures below.

    GAAP diluted EPS rose from $3.26 in FY2021 to $5.47 in FY2025.

    Open source ↗
  • Butterfield’s franchise should be underwritten as a high-profitability, limited-growth bank unless it proves it can add deposits, clients or markets without diluting returns.HoldingMateriality: Medium

    Total assets were $14.09 billion at FY2025 year-end, below $15.34 billion at FY2021 year-end. This determines the right valuation lens: steady compounding and distributions can work, but a growth-bank multiple would require evidence not visible in the served data.

    Watch: A successful expansion in Bermuda, Cayman, Channel Islands or adjacent offshore markets adds durable low-cost deposits and fee mandates.

    Supporting sources

    Source notes are factual paraphrases; read the original disclosures below.

    Total assets were $14.09 billion at FY2025 year-end, below $15.34 billion at FY2021 year-end.

    Open source ↗
Full investment case & evidence

Loading the original research archive…

Original research

Butterfield’s offshore relationship franchise lets it convert client deposits and liquidity into spread revenue without needing aggressive asset growth. If this holds, owners get a capital-light, high-return bank; if deposits reprice or leave, earnings power can fall before the balance sheet visibly shrinks.

Trust, wealth and custody-style client relationships should make Butterfield less volatile than a loan-growth bank, provided offshore clients keep mandates with the platform. Persistent fee and relationship income would support a higher-quality earnings stream; mandate losses would make profits more cyclical and easier to underwrite at a lower multiple.

Butterfield’s value creation depends on conservative liquidity and credit discipline, because a small offshore bank has less room to absorb deposit flight, securities losses or localized credit shocks. A clean, liquid balance sheet keeps capital available for dividends, buybacks and client confidence; a credit or liquidity event would reprice the franchise sharply.

Excess capital can compound owner value through per-share growth only if regulators and balance-sheet needs allow Butterfield to keep returning capital instead of retaining it defensively. This is the bridge from a good bank to a good stock: capital return can lift diluted EPS, but it disappears quickly if capital buffers need rebuilding.

Butterfield’s franchise should be underwritten as a high-profitability, limited-growth bank unless it proves it can add deposits, clients or markets without diluting returns. This determines the right valuation lens: steady compounding and distributions can work, but a growth-bank multiple would require evidence not visible in the served data.

All standing thesis claims
Original report summary

its island deposit base, fiduciary relationships, and capital returns prove more durable than a rate-sensitive bank multiple implies.

Evidence assessed Nov 21, 2026. Expand each conclusion for its evidence and what would change it. Thesis evidence—not a buy or sell recommendation.

Bull case and bear case

Bull case and bear case for Bank of N.T. Butterfield & Son

Where the evidence on Bank of N.T. Butterfield & Son stands: Holding on the latest evidence (Nov 21, 2026). Of its 5 thesis points, 3 strengthening and 2 holding.

Bull case: what the evidence supports

  • Butterfield’s offshore relationship franchise lets it convert client deposits and liquidity into spread revenue without needing aggressive asset growth.

    sec.gov ↗

  • Trust, wealth and custody-style client relationships should make Butterfield less volatile than a loan-growth bank, provided offshore clients keep mandates with the platform.

    sec.gov ↗

  • Butterfield’s value creation depends on conservative liquidity and credit discipline, because a small offshore bank has less room to absorb deposit flight, securities losses or localized credit shocks.

    sec.gov ↗

  • Excess capital can compound owner value through per-share growth only if regulators and balance-sheet needs allow Butterfield to keep returning capital instead of retaining it defensively.

    sec.gov ↗

  • Butterfield’s franchise should be underwritten as a high-profitability, limited-growth bank unless it proves it can add deposits, clients or markets without diluting returns.

    sec.gov ↗

Bear case: what would count against it

  • Bermuda, Cayman or Channel Islands customers move operating cash into U.S. Treasury funds, money-market funds or global private-bank sweep products.

    sec.gov ↗

  • Global fiduciary competitors such as Northern Trust, HSBC or major private banks win offshore trust and custody mandates from Butterfield clients.

    sec.gov ↗

  • A tourism, commercial real estate or captive-insurance downturn in Butterfield’s island markets creates outsized credit losses.

    sec.gov ↗

Thesis-Break Engine

Thesis-break watch · Bank of N.T. Butterfield & Son

12 mo agonow
Trailing daily price. No thesis break has crossed here, so there is no break base rate to project.

No break has crossed Bank of N.T. Butterfield & Son’s thesis. Its break conditions are checked against every new filing as it lands.

How the Thesis-Break Engine works →Historical outcomes are measured against the market after past breaks of the same kind, across all companies. Not a prediction.

MARKET + FINANCIAL SNAPSHOT

The numbers behind the thesis

Sourced from filings and market data

What Changed

  1. Mixed
    Foreign issuer material report (6-K).

    Bank of N.T. Butterfield & Son filed an SEC report on 2026-11-20: Foreign issuer material report (6-K). It is a dated development that tests the current thesis.

  2. Mixed
    6-K CIBC CARIBBEAN UNAUDITED CONDENSED CONSOLIDATED AND CARVE-OUT FINANCIALS.

    Bank of N.T. Butterfield & Son filed an SEC report on 2026-11-16: 6-K CIBC CARIBBEAN UNAUDITED CONDENSED CONSOLIDATED AND CARVE-OUT FINANCIALS. It is a dated development that tests the current thesis.

  3. Mixed
    6-K BNTB Q3 2026 RESULTS.

    Bank of N.T. Butterfield & Son filed an SEC report on 2026-10-27: 6-K BNTB Q3 2026 RESULTS. It is a dated development that tests the current thesis.

Risks / falsifiers

What could break the thesis

  • Bermuda, Cayman or Channel Islands customers move operating cash into U.S. Treasury funds, money-market funds or global private-bank sweep products.
  • Global fiduciary competitors such as Northern Trust, HSBC or major private banks win offshore trust and custody mandates from Butterfield clients.
  • A tourism, commercial real estate or captive-insurance downturn in Butterfield’s island markets creates outsized credit losses.
  • Bermuda or other regulators require higher capital buffers, limiting dividends or buybacks.
  • A successful expansion in Bermuda, Cayman, Channel Islands or adjacent offshore markets adds durable low-cost deposits and fee mandates.

NTB news

Loading headlines…

Financial statements

NTB income statement

Annual filed results · USD · Oldest to newest. Margins are calculated from the reported figures.

NTB: quick answers

What is NTB's short interest?
As of October 30, 2026, 694,046 NTB shares were sold short, down 13.6% from the count before. At the stock's average daily volume that is 4.2 days to cover. FINRA publishes the count twice a month. NTB short interest history
ScoutJUST THIS STORY

LET’S MAKE THIS USEFUL · 1 OF 5

How would you like me to explain this?

Tell me what you want from this read. Start with a quick note, then adjust the details. Your other stories stay as they are.

We’ll remember your view of this story. The published article stays unchanged.

THIS STORY’S READING VIEWStandard · The whole picture

Clear explanations with context. Both sides of the evidence.