What happened
Alejandro Gustavo Elsztain, a director of Cresud, Inc. (NASDAQ: CRESY), bought about $134,672 in common shares and American depositary shares for his direct holdings. The share counts aren't comparable one for one: Each American depositary share represents 10 common shares.
Elsztain bought 220 common shares at $0.97 each on Nov. 13, then made a larger purchase at a lower price. He bought 37,279 common shares at $0.93 each on Nov. 16.
He then bought 5,830 American depositary shares at $8.56 each on Nov. 18 and 6,220 at $8.02 each on Nov. 20. As with the common shares, he bought more shares at a lower price on the second trade.
Why it matters
The Form 4 shows how each position changed between its first and second purchases. Elsztain’s direct common-share holdings rose from 7,520,138 after the Nov. 13 trade to 7,557,417 after the Nov. 16 trade. His direct American depositary share holdings rose from 1,257,223 after the Nov. 18 trade to 1,263,443 after the Nov. 20 trade.
Elsztain paid in Argentine pesos for the common shares: ARS 1,625.95 per share on Nov. 13 and ARS 1,522.13 on Nov. 16. The filing used implied exchange rates of 1,674.54 pesos per U.S. dollar for the first purchase and 1,677.21 for the second.
To get those rates, the filing compared common-share closing prices on Bolsas y Mercados Argentinos with American depositary share closing prices. It used prices from the day of each common-share trade and accounted for the 10-to-1 share ratio.
The filing shows a change in one director’s holdings, not a change in the investment case. OptimistFi’s view still turns on whether Cresud’s hard assets hold their value and whether its cyclical cash flow produces returns for shareholders.
Explain the financial terms
A Form 4 is the SEC report an officer, director or 10% owner files within two business days of buying or selling the company's stock.
What's next
Cresud’s next quarterly report is the next test. Stronger operating cash flow and lower debt would support OptimistFi’s view.

