Kalshi warns New York order could shut it down nationwide
On November 23, a New York judge will hear the state's request for temporary limits on Kalshi, a prediction market and perps venue. The attorney general's office says Kalshi could continue to offer lawful futures and swaps.
Kalshi warned that New York's proposed temporary order could force it to close customers' trades early across the country. According to CoinCentral, Kalshi spokeswoman Elisabeth Diana said 1.2 million people use the exchange in New York alone.
Attorney General Letitia James wants to bar Kalshi from running an unlicensed gambling business "within or from New York or to persons in New York". Kalshi is based in the state, so its lawyer told the court the order could reach customers well beyond New York.
| What to check | Details |
|---|---|
| Geographic reach sought | "within or from New York or to persons in New York," CoinCentral reported |
| Age provision | Would bar users under 21 from trading under the proposed order, CoinCentral reported |
| Event contracts covered by the request | Sports, culture, elections and other events, CoinCentral reported |
| Value of open positions in Kalshi markets tracked by OptimistFi's hourly feed | $75.4 million across 122 markets |
| Hearing on temporary limits | November 23 at 11:30 a.m. Eastern Time, CoinCentral reported |
CoinCentral reported that the proposed order would limit sports, culture, election and other event contracts. It would also bar users under 21 from trading. James's office said it was not seeking to shut down the exchange and that Kalshi could still offer lawful futures and swaps.
Why it matters
With a Kalshi event contract, a trader can take either side of a yes-or-no question, such as whether a candidate will win an election. If the exchange has to close the trade early, the trader loses the chance to wait for the result that determines the payout.
On November 22, open positions across the 122 Kalshi markets in OptimistFi's hourly feed were worth $75.4 million. The reading does not establish which contracts the proposed order would cover.
Kalshi also lists perps, which are futures with no expiry date. U.S. residents can trade them on Kalshi.
How the case returned to state court
New York's Gaming Commission issued Kalshi a cease-and-desist on October 24, 2025, over what it called an "unlicensed mobile sports wagering platform". Kalshi sued the commission in federal court to block it from enforcing the state's gambling laws.
A judge denied Kalshi a preliminary injunction in that separate case on July 7, 2026. Kalshi's appeal remained pending when James's case returned to state court.
James filed her own suit on July 31, seeking to permanently stop what she alleges is an unlicensed gambling business. Kalshi moved it to federal court that day.
U.S. District Judge Vernon Broderick sent the suit back on November 19. His ruling settled which court would hear James's case, leaving the legality of the contracts under state law unresolved.
The Commodity Futures Trading Commission, the federal agency that regulates U.S. derivatives markets, made a second emergency bid to stop the state case. U.S. District Judge Lorna Schofield denied it on November 20.
What's next
Justice Melissa Crane is scheduled to hear the request on November 23 at 11:30 a.m. Eastern Time. For customers outside New York holding through settlement, the questions are whether any order keeps the words "from New York" and how it treats lawful futures and swaps.


